Unable to sharpen
"I loved this pencil when I first bought it. However, when I needed to sharpen it it got very jaggy pointed dangerous edges. Would appreciate advice on how to sharpen without that result."
PRO TIP: Sharpen with the Revlon Universal Points™ Sharpener as needed to get a sharply defined look. Simply insert the tip of the pencil and twist until you reach your desired length.
Overall rating: 4.2494984 / 5 from 1495 reviews.
Revlon ColorStay Multiplayer Eye Pencil offers a sharpenable pencil with a blending brush for endless eye looks that last all day. Customers praise its smooth application, creamy formula, and long-lasting pigment. The eyeliner provides a natural yet glam look and stays on all day.
Review topics: [irritation, results, quality, felt, color, feels, design, issues, texture, consistency, packaging, price, formula, skin, box, liner, look, eyes, shade, line, touch, lid, liquid, use, smooth, coverage, shape, using, pressure, style].
"I loved this pencil when I first bought it. However, when I needed to sharpen it it got very jaggy pointed dangerous edges. Would appreciate advice on how to sharpen without that result."
"Super easy flow. I like thin line and more natural look. Best I found. Get a new sharpener ladies. There are no issues with sharpening! This is the main reason for this review. . . . . . . smh. :woman-facepalming:. Last a long time too."
"First impression of the texture is totally swiped away by the fact that there’s almost no chance to sharpen the pencil. So after couple of days of use it’s over. One of 5 sharpeners can really sharpen the hard material and even if it does the soft core breaks during sharpening. Practically unusable."
"I see the reviews that it's too hard to sharpen. I googled it and it said to put it in the freezer for a bit before you sharpen. I'm going to try it and hope it works. I'm hooked on one of the colors so I'm hopeful!"
"It's short and DOESN'T extend past what you see. It is NOT sharpenable. It lasts about 10 days. At $12. 00 that's A TOTAL RIPOFF."
"Sharpenable … really. What a fail. I tried two different sharpeners. Just crack and clogs. Have to toss it. Too bad I liked it but got like 1/4” of use."
"Mine doesn't swirl, allow for ""sharpening"", and only lasted about 2 weeks, if that. Totally bogus."
"It works good but good luck sharpening it! It is VERY hard to sharpen. As you try the color melts, breaks off and sticks to the inside of the sharpening chamber. WHY do they use plastic and not wood? They plant trees in the southern states for this very reason - sustainable. I'm going to try to freeze it first next time to see if I get a better result. It's so expensive to just use it a few times."
"I was super happy with the product until I needed to sharpen it. I tried all the pencil sharpeners (small, big, different shapes) and it is impossible to sharpen it. This is waste of money!"
"I love this eyeliner! I did buy a revlon sharpener because I saw on the package that it was a pencil that would need a sharpener. The sharpener I had at home wouldn’t sharpen any eye pencil I had tried. I would absolutely recommend the eyeliner and the sharpener. Also, I think it would be great if it just came with a sharpener."