terrible!
"not able to clean it up, tidy it, or remove. I will throw it away immediately. It is NOT useable!"
Description
Line without limits and create the eye looks of your imagination with this double-ended, long-lasting eyeliner. 1: Kohl pencil for classic lining and tightlining or sultry, smoky eyes. The creamy, comfortable kohl formula is lightweight and lasts all day. 2: Flip it and the high-performance liquid eyeliner end draws sharp, thin to bold graphic lines. The smooth pigment-rich formula delivers intense color that won’t fade and lasts up to 24 hours.* Both ends deliver waterproof performance. Available in 4 double-ended shades.
*Fadeproof, comfortable wear.
Details
- Double ended for lining without limits
- Versatile liquid liner and kohl application
- High-performance, high-pigment liquid liner
- Precision brush tip draws sharp lines
- Creamy kohl retractable pencil
- Creates classic and smoky looks
- Waterproof and transferproof
- 4 double-ended shades
- Up to 48-hour wear
How To Use It
- Using creamy kohl pencil end, apply to waterline from inner corner and work outward using soft motions, draw kohl along your top lashes, follow along lower lash line for total kohl look
- Create a modern smoky eye by building up the kohl, blending and smudging out for a sultry look
- Using liquid eyeliner end, start from the inner corner of your eye and draw a single line along your lash line for a sharp fine line
- Or, to build on it for a thicker look or cat-eye, add a second, shorter line above the first (just at the last third of your lashes), then fill in the empty space
More to Love
Bold beauty choices to help perfect your look…
Overall rating: 4.152672 / 5 from 1048 reviews.
AI Generated Review Summary
The ColorStay Line Creator Double Ended Liner offers a creamy, comfortable kohl formula that is lightweight, waterproof, and long-lasting. Customers appreciate its bold and beautiful colors, dramatic look, and ability to create sharp lines. While some find the application challenging and the liquid side easier to use, the overall consensus is positive, especially regarding its long-lasting nature.
Summary topics
- Color (21%): Many customers loved the beautiful and bold colors of the liner, although some found it difficult to work with.
- Eyeliner (31%): A substantial number of customers raved about the eyeliner, praising its ease of use and beautiful color.
- Look (9%): Customers expressed satisfaction with the look of the eyeliner, mentioning that it was dramatic, easy to apply, and lasted all day.
- Application (9%): Customers have mixed opinions about the application, with some finding it smooth and easy, while others feel it holds too much.
- Line Creation (8%): Customers appreciated the ability to create sharp lines with the liner and the crayon option.
Review topics: [size, color, improvement, issues, quality, feels, texture, fits, value, skin, packaging, felt, look, amount, bottle, price, liquid, eyes, formula, works, shade, consistency, power, liner, lid, shape, touch, line, style, recommend].
Review highlights
- "The liquid side is very long lasting and gives a nice clean line." —
- "It has a nice solid black color and a thin enough brush to apply for some quick wing." —
- "The liquid liner is very fine and allows easy lines while the crayon gently glides along your lower lashline." —
Reviews
Once Dry, It Won't Budge
"Wish I could rate it higher than 5 stars. I've purchased a ridiculous number of black liquid eyeliners, from very expensive to the cheapest on the market but this is the best I've tried. Once it dries, it stays. I have oily lids and always ended up with eyeliner everywhere before this one. It stays put, even if I fall asleep before removing. The pencil side, I never use."
Sticky. So sticky.
"Not smooth at all. Sticky and ridiculously difficult to remove. The crayon is also bad. You will smooch it before you are halfway done."
Horrible!
"Suck!!!! First time I opened it … the crayon part fell out. And the the liquid liner isn’t designed good. The brush is too flimsy and the stem gets too much liquid liner on it which makes it hard and gets on your lashes."
Best eyeliner
"Best eyeliner I've ever used. It stays in without smudging or running"
Great, but apply carefully.
"I love the fact that the product stays on without smudging ONCE IT IS COMPLETELY DRY. I've never used an eyeliner that stays on this well, and I've tried at least 30 over the years. HOWEVER, if you mess up while applying it, you have to correct it immediately. Other issue is that it is hard to remove at the end of the day. Normal cleanser (Cetaphil) does not remove it well. Some makeup remover cloths don't work. You have to really rub it with the remover cloth to remove it. I'm now very careful when applying and love the look. TRULY WISH THEY WOULD MAKE THIS PRODUCT IN PURPLE!!!!"
Does not wipe off if you make a mistake.
"I purchased what I thought was a blue liner, turned out to be black. When I applied it I made a wonky line so tried to wipe it off, it didn't come off. I tried a tissue, then a damp tissue then a makeup wipe, it still didn't come off. It did fade a bit but it is still noticeable. I know the label says Colorstay and long wearing, but when I couldn't tidy up a mistake or wipe it off, that's really not ideal."
love the liquid part but not the crayon
"So this one has 2 different type of eyeliner in 1 thing. Which is super handy. However I’m not a fan of the crayon part. color is perfect but since my skin is oily it’s easily smudge. The liquid part is perfect byt thebrush is too thin. It stays and totally a longwear product which is great! Go give this one a try if you don’t have oily skin i think it’ll be perfect eyeliner"
Revlon colorstay line Creator Double Ended liner
"It is a double pencil and liquid eyeliner with a very fine brush, easy to use, both have a very low pigmentation."
Good pigment
"Pigment is good for the brush. The pencil is a bit lighter. Yet both are smudge proof."