Overall rating: 4.378531 / 5 from 708 reviews.
The ColorStay Brow Creator™ offers a micro-sculpting eyebrow pencil and powder duo that customers appreciate for its ability to fill, define, and shape brows naturally. The pencil's color is great for filling sparse spots, and the spoolie and brush blend the product well. However, opinions on the powder vary, with some finding it too intense.
Review topics: ["size","color","quality","fits","results","design","spots","issues","skin","feels","packaging","line","amount","formula","texture","liner","look","hair","shade","buy","shape","coverage","eyes","works","style","consistency","light","difference","use","using"].
"Accurate shade and coverage very good, it stays a long time and the tiny brush in the end is very convenient. Pretty suitable for makeup bags. It’s easy to use."
"Goes on smooth and as natural as “fake” brows can look. Make sure you get the right color bc it can look a little odd if it’s not. It’s lasted most of the day but seemed to like bleed or blur out a little. I guess I’m not a fan of coloring in brows especially when I don’t have a full face of makeup. The product was good I just prefer nothing on my brows. They looked too dark on me or unnatural or something but crucial to blend them out with a spoolie."
"This 3 in 1 is perfect for me. Brush to shape, fill and define with pencil and sculpt with the powder. Both waterproof and smudge proof. Last most of the day, few touch-ups if over 12 hours. Like that everything is all in one long container. Easy to use and put in a purse or pocket. A little bit of cleanser and washed off. Affordable and highly recommend."
"I’ve been using the Revlon ColorStay Brow Creator for a few weeks now, and I’m genuinely impressed. It’s a 3-in-1 product that includes a pencil, a spoolie, and a powder — super convenient for everyday use or travel. The pencil tip is precise and allows for hair-like strokes, making it easy to fill in sparse areas naturally. The powder gives a soft finish and adds volume without looking overdone. It also lasts all day without smudging, which is a big plus for me, especially in Florida humidity."
"A family member gave me this pencil because it was the wrong color for her. I found the color and texture to be superior; however, the plastic cartridge holds a very small piece of product that lasted only ten weeks. Refills are not available. This not only detracts from the value of the product but also contributes unnecessarily to the plastic waste problem. We've got to do better for the environment."
"Revlon ColorStay Brow Creator fills in brows easily and stays on all day. It has a pencil, powder, and brush all in one, so it’s super handy. The color looks natural and doesn’t rub off."
"This was my favorite eyebrow pencil for awhile it was the only one I used. I noticed recently there was a formula change along with a price change. The new formula is horrible I compare it to crayola crayons now. Please go back to the old formula."
"Not colorstay And i tried ti upload a photo and it would not let me."
"For the price, colorstay brow creator micro tip pencil and powder is not worth it."
"This is my perfect pencil when i want to look glam, classy and have perfect eyebrows. Great pigment, tinny point , precise and easy to use. One unique thing i must say is that if you press too hard it break easily. The packaging is great and come with a little but helpful spollie brush in the other side,"
