Overall rating: 4.3072114 / 5 from 2399 reviews.
The ColorStay™ Liquid Eyeliner offers a dramatic look with a waterproof and smudgeproof formula that lasts up to 16 hours. Customers appreciate its precise tip, smooth application, and long-lasting color. The thin and flexible brush provides easy gliding and great color payoff.
Review topics: [size, results, quality, fits, color, improvement, feels, scent, design, value, texture, felt, consistency, packaging, package, issues, amount, formula, skin, price, look, bottle, eyes, liner, shape, liquid, lid, line, shade, alternative].
"This is a great eyeliner minus the brush. It is so thick. The brush that comes with the Micro Easy Precision Liquid Liner is amazing and thin. It is much easier to get a nice line, but I really hate the waterproof formula of the Micro Easy. It caused a bad lesion on my lower lid which left a scar. Please reconsider the brush."
"There are threads everywhere bemoaning the discontinuation of Skinny Mahogany Flame. You can't even find it on eBay anymore. WHY REVLON???? You had so many dedicated fans. I can't find anything at any price that competes. I refuse to buy anything else from Revlon if they don't care what their customers want."
"I love this eyeliner so much it’s one of my go to! Even the brown color is so pretty. Stays on all day and doesn’t melt down on face. Dries on face quickly as well and there is never any creasing. Very easy to use and the packaging is easy. No flaking. No need to shake to use either."
"Please bring the old skinny applicator back!!!! I had to look for another option in a different company brand because of this issue. Also, mahogany flame color is very much missed."
"When I tell you this is the best drugstore eyeliner I mean it! I am very picky! I have bought high end low end and this has always been my fave! It’s budget friendly and reliable. It doesn’t smear after it dries , it doesn’t flake or run. My eyes get super oily throughout the day and it hasn’t affected anything. If you rub your eyes this probably isn’t for you though. But it truly is an amazing eyeliner! It doesn’t fade it is long lasting ! The finish is matte! The formula is medium not to thick and not too runny. Is easy to clean off if you mess up"
"I did notice creasing and flaking with this, however the application was easy and it did last a few hours into a very busy nursing shift! I didnt feel this on my skin in a caked on way and it was easy to remove with makeup remover."
"I love how you can easily control the tip to thick or thin lines! The packaging is good, not too bulky. And the fact that it's not flaking after long hours of wear. Easy to remove and no strong scent."
"The formula is indeed liquid, and is actually a bit runny. The product can be too much when you first take the wand out of the bottle, but otherwise is ok. Wait to dry before curling lashes and applying mascara, as it will smudge and transfer easily when wet."
"I used this product a few years ago. . and it was great! Loved that it stayed on for awhile. The application was ok the did take a it to get it on properly will try again"
"This Revlon Liquid liner has been my all-time favorite easy to wear, not fading sharp tip, which gives lovely shape whenever u apply, and last but not least, very dark black khol and smudge proof"
